Pick all the bicycles in this picture? (Insert your screams.)
For those that aren’t yet aware: the trade off with the technology behind eliminating bot-detection here comes with a huge compromise. That trade off is that Big Tech companies need to basically certify that your device is capable and valid in order to access a website. “They” can decide at any moment to deny you access to sites that you request, which is a massive detriment to the free and open web. It’s one step below a censored internet and it’s already started rolling out in Safari.
So let me guess, the point is to get rid of AdBlockers isn‘t it? I liked my iPhone, but if they fuck with AdGuard I‘ll switch. Google seems to be spearheading this though, and if they get AWS/Azure etc on board, will there be any way to escape it at all? This worries me a bit.
So… they’re saying it should be up to the browser to prove that the user is a human?
That seems like a terrible idea to me…what’s to stop an automated browser from just saying yes, I’m totally a human ?
There isn’t. This article is laughable because there is an astronomical amount of bot traffic that masquerades as legitimate human traffic. Things like puppeteer extra stealth and residential proxies have made it easier to hide a bots presence on the web. Also, the tracking they allude to via fingerprinting would very much be the same whether it’s a human solving a captcha or a seamless process where your browser solves one.
If they manage to standardize an attestation API, they can swiftly kill off that possibility, as well as the possibility of any new successful operating systems / device manufacturers via the natural user growth that benefited the current hegemons.
Fock off with that DRM shit
Ah yes googles new api with drm will make a fine solution to captcha.
Captchas also compromise your privacy. When you run across a Captcha, the technology might keep a permanent record of your phone or computer identity that can track everywhere you go online.
Humans also fiddle with a computer mouse or move around a touch screen phone in a “very human way,” Graham-Cumming said, so the ticketing computer might scope out how the cursor is moving.
Not sure why privacy is brought up if it seems to be equally as bad?
The new captcha in an AI world will be like “Caption this politically charged cartoon in 5 words or less”
“IT IS IMPORTANT TO NOTE” – You’re a bot
"NO I AM DEFINITELY NOT " – BOT
"AS AN AI LANGUAGE MODEL " – SILENCE, BOT
I sure am. I wish I could just be a robot already so I fit in.
